ROAD TO FREEDOM GEORGE DE CHARMS 1941
NEW CHURCH LIFE
VOL. LXI
JANUARY, 1941
No. 1
(Delivered at Pittsburgh and Ontario District Assemblies, 1940.)
The deepest longing of every human heart is to be free. This is of Divine provision, because in freedom alone can true and lasting happiness be given. Yet freedom cannot be imparted as an obvious gift of the Creator. It must, to all appearance, be achieved through patient labor and continual conflict. The life-story of every individual-and indeed the entire history of the race-may be summed up in this ceaseless struggle for ever greater liberation. The hope of attaining a larger measure of freedom is the mainspring of life,-the driving power of all human progress and development. When that hope dies, life loses its significance, and becomes a burden rather than a joy.
There was perhaps never a time in the history of the world when that hope was at lower ebb than it is today. Men seem to have tried every possible road that might lead to the freedom they are seeking, only to find that it ends in the bogs and quicksands of a new enslavement. The way of conquest led to the partial and temporary liberation of the few at the expense of the many; but in time it always brought revolt that overturned the seats of the mighty, reduced them to subservience, and replaced them with another few to enjoy a brief period of power. For many centuries, religious faith was regarded as the great liberator; but this also entered the lists of conquest, seeking dominion over the souls of men. And this led again to revolt, to doctrinal disputes and sectarian strife that left freedom prostrate in its path.
At last men turned to scientific knowledge, to an understanding recognition of natural laws, seeking liberation in the rule of reason. Meeting with unprecedented success-making rapid progress in the mastery of the elements, the relief of human suffering, the a massing of material wealth, they imagined that they had discovered the secret of an ever-expanding freedom. With reason to guide, they thought they would be able, by negotiation, to solve every problem of the individual, the community, the nation, and the world itself, thus eliminating the threat of war, and turning all the forces of man's intelligence into the peaceful channels of productive and profitable trade for the highest benefit of all.
But at the height of their complacent assurance that the longed-for goal was just over the horizon, a rude awakening came when that ancient foe of freedom, the lust for conquest, again reared its head. Treaties were scrapped, negotiations were repudiated, and all the fruits of man's intelligent labor were turned into machines of destruction, directed once more at the subjugation of the many to the dominant will of the few. In the face of this cataclysm-which threatens to reduce civilization to smoking ruins, to extinguish the flame of enlightened reason, and to plunge the world into a new dark age of barbarism, with all its human tragedy-many are tempted to doubt whether, after all, freedom may not be but a chimera, impossible of attainment. Is there such a thing as progress? Or do we but plod in a treadmill, our eyes fixed on the moving walk in front of us, imagining that we are advancing, only to find that we have not gone forward, but remain exactly where we started, still held in the implacable grasp of those forces from which we have been striving to escape?
Yet, in this dark hour of discouragement and despair, a new light has been kindled by the Lord for those who have eyes to see. It is the light of Divine Revelation, giving a spiritually rational insight into the hidden purposes of God which lie back of this apparently confused and meaningless human drama. It gives us renewed assurance that there is such a thing as freedom-to which man can attain in spite of all the forces that oppose it. It gives us to know that there has been progress, steady and undeviating progress under the leading of the Divine Providence, toward the achievement of that freedom. For this, preparation has been made, and is now being made with infinite care and wisdom, through all the apparent failures and discouragements of human error.
3
It points to the one and only road that will lead to that supreme accomplishment, and teaches us how we may walk therein with courage and calm faith in the Lord, who has Himself come to lead us.
But what is this freedom for which we strive, and to which we at last may attain? It is not absolute freedom, for this is an attribute of life, and life belongs to God alone. Man is but a vessel, devoid of all life save that which perpetually inflows from God. He has no least power to move except under the impulse of the in- flowing stream of life. And because he is animated solely by a force that originates outside of himself, essential freedom cannot be ascribed to him; nor can he ever attain to it. But the Lord, wishing to give His life to man completely, that he may enjoy it altogether as if it were his own, insinuates it so secretly that man is entirely unaware of its influx. It appears to him to originate within himself, and thus to be his very own. From this appearance arises a sense of freedom, or rather a sense of the power to attain to ever greater freedom. In the exercise of this God-given power, and in the hope of our expanding freedom by the use of it, lies the joy of life.
The appearance to man that be has absolute and unrestricted freedom-that his life is his own, and that he can do with it whatever be desires-this is indeed an illusion. The truth is that he is under the perpetual government of the Lord, apart from whom he can do nothing. But the Lord does give him a limited form of freedom, which nonetheless is real, and with which He never interferes. This is the freedom to choose, in thought and will, between two opposites,-the freedom to reject the one, in order that he may accept the other. If this choice is evil, then its ultimation in speech and action will indeed be circumscribed, lest spiritual injury be done to others. But the thought and will are ever maintained in freedom, even with those who are in hell.
The fact that, for the protection of the good, the ultimation of such evil thought and will must be restrained, involves that this choice, though freely made, does not lead to freedom, but to bondage. On the other hand, if man freely chooses what is good, and for the sake of this rejects the evil that opposes it, then the expression of that good in word and deed can bring only good to others.
4
For it is in accord with those Divine laws by which the Lord provides for the greatest happiness of all; and man can be allowed unlimited freedom in ultimating it. Freedom, then,-that true and lasting freedom which lies within the reach of man's endeavor,-is the free choice of what is good, and the determined resistance to evil for the sake of good. In this freedom is the everlasting happiness of heaven.
The happiness of heaven can be received only in freedom. Life is love, and the joy or happiness of life is the free activity of love. If love is compelled, it dies. There is no joy in delights that are forced upon us. Even the joys of heaven would be forced upon us if we had no choice save to accept them as they are presented to us. Free acceptance is possible only with the freedom to reject,-to choose the opposite in preference. Wherefore, only so far as we freely choose heavenly delights, resisting what is evil in order that we may attain to them, can these delights impart to us a sense of joy and blessedness. This is the reason why the Lord does not create man already an angel of heaven, possessed of good and truth in all abundance, but places him on earth endowed merely with the ability to choose this good, and with an innate longing for the freedom that such a choice alone can give.
We are all familiar with the sphere of innocence and peace that surrounds a little infant. In this we see reflected as in a mirror the very happiness of heaven. From natural affection we might wish that the joys of this state could be retained. We might wish that the child could be spared the cares and anxieties, the responsibilities, the hardships and temptations, of adult life. We know that, as he grows, he will recede from innocence. Tendencies to evil will multiply, and he will be called upon to work, to struggle, to face failure, and loss, and suffering. Yet we know that the delights of infancy are not the joys of heaven for which he was created. The happiness of heaven is indefinitely greater than that of infancy. And in order that he may attain this higher blessing, the Lord has ordained that he shall grow up. To him there comes the Divine call that came to Abram: " Get thee out of thy country, and from thy kindred, and from thy father's house, unto a land that I will show thee."
This call is perceived as a deep longing to be free. The infant is not free. Even the delights that he enjoys are but loaned to him. They have not been chosen by him. They have been accepted without alternative, because he knows no other.
5
He is, in fact, utterly helpless. He has neither the strength nor the knowledge to cope with the forces of the world in which he finds himself. He must depend upon parents and guardians for all the necessaries of life. If he is to survive, he must learn to obey without questioning why. He is under the bonds of external command, and must be led and taught by fear of punishment and the promise of reward. Only by successive stages, by growth, by effort and application, can he acquire the knowledge and the judgment to direct his own way in accord with the unalterable laws of life. In attempting to do this, he will make many mistakes, will suffer many disappointments, will undergo many temptations, and in appearance will recede farther and farther from the innocence of infancy.
Yet it is only in this way that he can be given the possibility of a free choice-a free opportunity to reject what is evil and achieve what is good, as if by his own effort As he grows, acquiring wider knowledge and deeper understanding, this choice can be made at a higher and higher level. And the more exalted the plane of choice, the more complete is the sense of freedom, and the greater the delight that choice imparts. This is the purpose of growth-the end of the Divine Providence in growth-that the plane of choice may be lifted up by successive steps even to what is heavenly and eternal.
That some-when this opportunity is given-should choose the evil and reject the good is a necessary permission, in order that all may, if they will, choose the good and reject the evil. There is no other way to provide real freedom and real choice. For if it were so ordered that the choice of evil were impossible, then good would have to be accepted, and could not be received in freedom.
As with the individual, so also with the race. Human life began in a Golden Age of racial infancy. Innocence reigned. Love and charity universally prevailed. Evil, with its suffering, was unknown. Yet the delights of that age were not those that the Lord foresaw as the final goal of His creation. For men, even after they had grown to adult age, were spiritually infants. They did not, and could not, enjoy the blessings of spiritual maturity. They were dependent upon external direction and control. They spoke with the Lord face to face. He appeared to them as the Angel of Jehovah, telling them openly what they should speak and do.
6
Their happiness lay in a willing, unquestioning obedience to commands, the import of which they did not deeply understand. It lay in the acknowledgment of their own ignorance and helplessness, and in an innocent desire to be led in all things by the Lord.
But the Lord did not wish them to remain in that state. He wanted them to grow up, to increase in independence, to enjoy a greater appearance of freedom-to accumulate knowledges, and become intelligent and wise, in order that He might lead them more subtly, meeting them on a higher plane, and giving a greater portion of their life as it were into their own hands. That in this process of growth temptations would come, tendencies to evil would multiply, and conflicts would increase in intensity and bitterness, was necessary, if indeed the end were at last to be attained. But through all the trials that were in store for them. He ordained that every stage of their development should prepare them to receive a greater measure of freedom, until at last they became spiritually adult, capable of entering intellectually into the mysteries of faith, capable of understanding a rational revelation, and thus of assuming a full measure of responsibility for free cooperation with the Lord by a rational observance of the Divine laws of life.
That this is true, we can see in some measure if we compare the three Revelations that remain to us-the Old Testament, the New Testament, and the Writings. They depict the measure of spiritual freedom which could be given in the childhood, the youth, and the adult age of the race, respectively. The Old Testament represents government by direct command, especially by the command " Thou shalt not." The evils to be avoided are minutely specified. They are, for the most part, evils of outward act, prohibited, not because of rational considerations that are known and understood, but because the Lord has said so. They demand no more than willing obedience to the commandments of an all-wise Father, in whose infinite wisdom men were to place unquestioning confidence. If obedience was not given, it was enforced by external punishments. As to the deeper reasons why these statutes and judgments should be observed, teaching could not yet be given, because it could not be understood.
The New Testament, however, is addressed to a more advanced state,-a state of spiritual youth, when the ability to understand the reasons was being gradually acquired.
7
It contains the generals of doctrine, often clothed in parables, but so clearly apparent as to encourage the effort of spiritual thinking. It gave to the world a new and higher kind of spiritual freedom, and required a greater measure of individual responsibility for the formulation and interpretation of doctrine. It prepared the way for the spread of education, and for the increase of natural knowledge, without which a rational understanding of spiritual truth could not be given. It insinuated the ideals of life that laid the foundation for greater civil and political liberty. All this was accomplished in spite of the fall of the Christian Church and the falsities of doctrine that arose from the first youthful effort to solve the riddle of life before the rational faculty was as yet mature.
And finally, in the Heavenly Doctrine, we find a Revelation that enables man to enter progressively into a spiritually rational understanding of truth. It sets forth the relation of the Infinite to the finite; the laws of creation, and of continual preservation operative in the universe; the laws of redemption, and of regeneration. It discloses the nature of the spiritual world, and of the life after death. It makes known the modes of influx from that world into nature, and the interdependence between spirits and men. It makes possible a true interpretation of the laws of nature, that they may be seen as tools in the Lord's hand for the accomplishment of His eternal ends. All this, in order to introduce man into a higher kind of freedom. For through a knowledge of these laws man is enabled to direct his life freely, as if of himself, in accord with the Divine Order. He can assume the responsibility that belongs to a spiritual adult age, and can enjoy his faculties of liberty and rationality on a plane never before possible to the human race.
The primary cause of the threatened collapse of modern civilization is to be found in the fact that men, having lost all perception of spiritual truth, have sought to attain to freedom by means of natural reason alone. This, the Writings tell us, will produce the external appearance of freedom. It will cleanse the outside of the cup and the platter by removing evils in their external manifestation. The rational acknowledgment of natural laws as superior to our individual will, and the recognition of the fact that observance of these laws tends to promote the greatest good for the greatest number, leads to a measure of self-discipline that establishes a state of external order.
8
It supports honesty, sincerity, justice, and the moral virtues. It encourages a spirit of tolerance, and promotes freedom of speech and of the press. Natural reason points to these things as the only foundation upon which a sound social structure may be erected. But the end in view is purely natural. It is to satisfy the external desires and ambitions of men. By these means, men strive for wealth, position, reputation, fame, and power, which are mistaken for the supreme good for the sake of which society exists. And within them lie the evils of self-love and greed, untouched by such a natural morality,-evils that fester under the surface, causing various forms of corruption that pour out poisons into the body politic, and from time to time burst their external bonds to wreak destruction upon society.
The real cause of human bondage lies in these deeper evils that flourish in hidden recesses of the mind, withdrawn from the sight of others. Such evils are beyond the reach of natural laws. Natural reasoning alone gives us no power to remove them. Yet, if they are not removed, they will secretly qualify and subtly vitiate our outward appearance of morality, turning that morality to the service of their own ends, and in time of stress repudiating it and casting off its restraints.
There is only one power adequate to effect this removal, namely, the power of a spiritual religion-the acknowledgment of God, and the shunning of evil as sin against Him. This involves the recognition of a higher law-a law of spiritual and eternal life,-to be found only in the teaching of Divine Revelation. The observance of this law from an inmost love to the Lord, and a desire worthily to serve and honor Him, this alone is adequate to the removal of evils from the internal man, and thus to bring true and lasting liberation from the bondage of evil. As we read in the work on the Divine Providence:
Spiritual freedom is from the love of eternal life. Into this love and its enjoyment no one comes but he who thinks evils to be sins and therefore does not will them, and who at the same time looks to the Lord. When a man first does this, he is in that freedom; for no one is able not to will evils because they are sins, and therefore not to do them, unless from the more interior or higher freedom, which is from the more interior or higher love.
9
At first this freedom does not seem to be freedom, yet still it is: but it afterwards appears so, and then man acts from freedom according to reason in thinking, willing, speaking, and doing what is good and true. This freedom increases as natural freedom decreases and becomes subservient; and it conjoins itself with rational freedom, and purifies it. Anyone can come into this freedom, provided he is willing to reflect that life is eternal, and that the temporary enjoyment and bliss of a life in time are but as a fleeting shadow compared with the never ending enjoyment and bliss of a life in eternity; and a man can think so if he wishes, because he has rationality and liberty, and because the Lord, from whom these two faculties are, continually gives the ability." (D. P. 73.)
Here, then, lies, the road to freedom-the road than can lead men back from the quagmire into which they have strayed to the attainment of that goal for which they have vainly sought. It is the path of internal self-denial, of internal self-compulsion, motivated by a spiritual vision of the Lord as He appears in His Second Coming, and by a rational understanding of the truth revealed in His opened Word. In this self-compulsion there is a higher freedom, which brings with it a more interior delight. But, to achieve it, man must assume a greater measure of individual responsibility than was required of him in previous ages. He must assume the responsibility of one spiritually adult. And to do so he must cultivate the love of spiritual truth,-the truth of eternal life. He must seek a knowledge of heaven, and a rational understanding of heaven's laws, in order that he may intelligently combat and overcome those deeper evils that infest the internal man. He must make this conflict the main concern, and victory in it the supreme goal of his life. In doing so he must remove from his mind all natural considerations, and act solely for the sake of obedience to the Lord and compliance with His eternal law. None can undertake this task save those who have access to that law-whose minds are open to receive in heart and faith the teaching of the Heavenly Doctrine. But all these are called by the Lord to follow this road that leads to freedom.
With the knowledge of the Lord's Coming; with the sense of His near presence; with the vision of this road charted plainly before us in the Writings; with full freedom to choose this path and advance along it, even though at first with slow and faltering steps; we have no need to fear the future.
10
He whose Providence has been guiding the destiny of the race from the beginning has led it safely through its infancy, childhood and youth to a state in which this Revelation could be given, and has preserved a remnant capable of receiving that new truth with gladness, He will not fail to provide for the eventual establishment of His Kingdom among men.
The world-events that are the cause of such deep and widespread concern are, under His Divine direction, but part of a necessary preparation for the New Church. They are the inevitable accompaniments of the Last Judgment-that final consummation which has come upon the Christian dispensation. Only through failure and suffering can confirmed falsities be shaken, and strongly intrenched indifference to spiritual things be softened, in the minds of men. And until this is done there is no possibility of a humble approach to Divine Revelation, that the truth of heaven may touch and move the hearts of men. Whatever the natural outcome, this is the Divine purpose that lies back of the present conflict, In the Lord's own time this purpose will be achieved, and the way will be opened for a wider acceptance of the New Church. Then men shall come to know a new freedom-an internal and lasting freedom that will bring untold joy and blessing to mankind.
This is in the Lord's hands. As to its final accomplishment, we need have no concern. Our duty lies in meeting the responsibility that is placed upon us by virtue of the fact that we have been given, in the Lord's mercy, to see the road that leads to freedom. If we are to prove worthy of this responsibility, we must, as individuals, freely choose that road and steadfastly walk therein. We must search daily in the Heavenly Doctrine for Divine instruction and guidance in our endeavor to remove the evils that are contrary to the laws of heaven-remove them not merely from our speech and action, but primarily from the thought and will of our internal man. By this endeavor the Lord will break the power of those evils over us, and establish His Kingdom in our hearts. If, as individuals, we will be faithful to this, the Lord will grant us illustration to meet the problems of life, and will bind us together in bonds of mutual love and charity, that the small beginnings of His Church among us may steadily increase in unity and strength.
11